NBC Pulls ‘Nurses’ Episode After Massive Backlash Over ‘Jew face,’ ‘Anti-Semitic’ Scene
NBC is pulling an episode of its medical drama Nurses after falling under heavy fire for an “anti-Semitic” scene, in which a Hasidic patient refuses a bone graft from a “goyim” — the Yiddish word for a non-Jewish person.
“The graft, where does it come from?” asks the Hasidic patient in the scene.
“It’s called an allo bone graft, it’s harvested from a deceased donor,” replies the doctor.
“A goyim leg, from anyone, an Arab? A woman?” asks a second Hasidic character.
“Or God forbid an Arab woman,” says a third character.
Allison Josephs — founder of the nonprofit organization Jew in the City — resurfaced the clip Tuesday on Twitter, where she included her blog post calling on NBC to apologize for its Nurses scene.
This is the malicious way @nbcnurses portrays Orthodox Jews. Read our response https://t.co/w7ifhHJIUy pic.twitter.com/nH8SD4cKFM
— Allison Josephs (@jewinthecity) February 23, 2021
“There is no prohibition on getting a dead body part surgically inserted into one’s body,” wrote Jospehs. “In fact, Jewish law says we should use the best medicine of our times to recover from our illnesses.”
“There is no prohibition to get a non-Jewish body part inserted, nor is there a prohibition if the part belongs to a woman or an Arab,” she added. “The idea that such a surgery would be problematic in general or problematic because of where the bone came from not only is categorically false according to Jewish law, it is a vicious lie that endangers men who walk around with curled side locks and black hats.”
Seffi Kogen, the head of Young Leadership at the American Jewish Committee (AJC), echoed Josephs sentiments, tweeting, “I think this is the most antisemitic thing I have ever seen in a TV show.”
Watch Below:
I think this is the most antisemitic thing I have ever seen in a TV show pic.twitter.com/oS1hPFIjcj
— Seffi Kogen (@seffikogen) February 24, 2021
“For those of you unfamiliar with Jewish law, which puts precedent on healing and saving lives, there is no prohibition on the kind of bone graft in this clip,” added Kogen in a follow-up tweet. “The writers made it up, dressed their actors in Jew-face, and put random extremist nonsense in their mouths.”
For those of you unfamiliar with Jewish law, which puts precedent on healing and saving lives, there is no prohibition on the kind of bone graft in this clip. The writers made it up, dressed their actors in Jew-face, and put random extremist nonsense in their mouths.
— Seffi Kogen (@seffikogen) February 24, 2021
Shortly after that, other social media users took to Twitter to express their dismay over the resurfaced clip.
“This warrants an apology and an explanation from @nbc,” wrote one Twitter user.
This warrants an apology and an explanation from @nbc. https://t.co/4pnXmifqFo
— Bethany S. Mandel (@bethanyshondark) February 24, 2021
“This is wrong on so many levels,” commented another.
This is wrong on so many levels https://t.co/qjpuqP5Fk3
— Evan Siegfried (@evansiegfried) February 24, 2021
“I guess ‘Jew face’ is ok but ‘black face’ is racist. And while full blown lying about how a family would handle a situation…. this world is disgusting,” wrote a third.
I guess “Jew face” is ok but “black face” is racist. And while full blown lying about how a family would handle a situation…. this world is disgusting https://t.co/s5aLB2eLsU
— CNC/DFS (@Homicidal_Apple) February 24, 2021
“This truly is shockingly anti-Semitic. Zero accuracy or truth to anything that is going on here. I am stunned @nbc would even consider airing this,” another Twitter user commented.
This truly is shockingly anti-Semitic. Zero accuracy or truth to anything that is going on here. I am stunned @nbc would even consider airing this. https://t.co/9KWfuHTYlQ
— Harley Kesselman (@harleykesselman) February 24, 2021
“The look, language, discussion of Jewish law. They literally got everything wrong,” tweeted another Twitter user. “Writers, directors, actors etc. should all be ashamed. But they won’t be. Jews. No biggie.”
“Ask yourself: Would this happen with any other religion/people? That’s how you know it’s anti-semitic,” the Twitter user added.
The look, language, discussion of Jewish law. They literally got everything wrong.
Writers, directors, actors etc. should all be ashamed.
But they won’t be. Jews. No biggie.
Ask yourself: Would this happen with any other religion/people? That’s how you know it’s anti-semitic. https://t.co/IgLDftyn4q
— Ephraim Gopin (@EphraimGopin) February 24, 2021
“What the f is this?” one Twitter user asked of the resurfaced Nurses clip.
What the f is this? https://t.co/ajAo8Y1kuX
— Tatjana Pasalic (@Tattytats) February 24, 2021
“This is the worst minute of television I have ever seen,” commented another. “It is 100% anti-semitic, and there is no jewish law covering what they are discussing. @nbc @nbcnurses should be ashamed.”
This is the worst minute of television I have ever seen. It is 100% anti-semitic, and there is no jewish law covering what they are discussing. @nbc @nbcnurses should be ashamed. #NBC #NursesNBC https://t.co/CCIvWStZlW
— Matthew ‘refusing to be silenced’ Broach (@i_c_crazy_matt) February 24, 2021
“I have a very good Jewish friend whose life was saved by a kidney donation from a Christian stranger,” said one Twitter user. “She read about his situation on Facebook and decided to save his life with one of her organs.”
“The idea that we Jews wouldn’t accept such generosity is anti-semitism straight up,” the Twitter user added.
I have a very good Jewish friend whose life was saved by a kidney donation from a Christian stranger. She read about his situation on Facebook and decided to save his life with one of her organs. The idea that we Jews wouldn’t accept such generosity is anti-semitism straight up. https://t.co/ng4NE8bwNP
— Joe Pilot, MD (@JoeSilverman7) February 24, 2021
“And thinks why we need a media detox. This is a straight up lie. Jewish law puts saving life above everything else. These are actors dressed liked Jews to make Jews look bad. This is anti-Semitic and NBC should be ashamed,” commented another.
And thinks why we need a media detox. This is a straight up lie. Jewish law puts saving life above everything else. These are actors dressed liked Jews to make Jews look bad. This is anti-Semitic and NBC should be ashamed. https://t.co/W3DGGWO0rl
— Daniel Lawson (@Lawdog85) February 24, 2021
After facing backlash from the social media users and Jewish organizations, NBC pulled the season finale from its digital platforms, according to a report by Deadline.
The scrutiny over the resurfaced Nurses clip comes after NBC’s Saturday Night Live (SNL) also facing backlash for an anti-Semitic joke about Israel and coronavirus vaccines.
You can follow Alana Mastrangelo on Facebook and Twitter at @ARmastrangelo, and on Instagram.
Comments are closed.