Israel’s Channel 14 caused outrage on Wednesday evening after Erel Segal and Shimon Riklin presented a particularly disturbing graph in their program, which suggested that right-wingers were more likely to survive October 7.
The graph clearly divides the percentage of those murdered and kidnapped from the towns up to 10 km from the Gaza border after the October 7 attack in a division between what they define as “right=coalition” towns and “left=opposition” towns.
אחת ההשערות של עורך הסקר היא שכיתות הכוננות ביישובי השמאל היו פחות ערוכים ומתורגלים למתקפה בגלל עמדותיהם הפוליטיות ולכן נהרגו שם יותר תושבים. לא יאומן שדבר כזה הגיע לטלויזיה pic.twitter.com/Bu8sDR0fU6
— yoav dekel (@YoYoavdekel) May 29, 2024
According to the data presented, there are 10 times more people murdered in “left = opposition” towns compared to what they called “right = coalition” towns.
Beyond the cynicism of correlating political position to the levels of horror experienced by one or another locality in Israel on October 7.
The graph ignored the number of terrorists who attacked each locality, the time it took for the IDF to reach each locality, the percentage of right- and left-wing voters in each locality (if you’re doing such a cynical study), and many other factors that need to be taken into account.
ללא בושה:”ישראל היום” (העיתון שלי) כנראה לא צפה באייטם שלנו.זה לא סקר ולא מחקר של ערוץ 14.ראיינו את ד”ר ליעד לוי, פיזיקאי, שערך מחקר ומצא נתונים סטטיסטים מובהקים שדורשים בדיקה כדי ללמוד להבא. לעתיד. הסטרייפ אמנם לא מוצלח (הכותרת במסך) אבל מי שצפה או יצפה באייטם יראה את… https://t.co/gZIVm2USbO
— Erel Segal אראל סגל (@ErelSegal) May 29, 2024
After presenting the graph, its editor even declared that the question should be asked as to whether “right-wing” communities were more ready to be attacked because of their political positions and also that it should be checked what the “level of support for the IDF” was between communities where there were such and such massacres.
Among the angry reactions registered after the publication of the graph, the journalist and presenter Ben Caspit wrote in a tweet on his X account: “This is what a derailment looks like.”
“Someone is funding this garbage,” another person said on X.
חברו את אל מנאר ואל ג׳זירה ולא תגיעו לרמת השנאה של ערוץ 14 למדינת ישראל ואזרחיה. הייתי אומר שהם סוכנים של האויב, אבל לא. הם – בעלי הערוץ, ומי שאחראי לאייטמים כמו זה – הם האויב בכבודו ובעצמו. https://t.co/9KZkRDS3Qb
— Yehuda Shohat (@yudash) May 29, 2024
“Connect Al Manar and Al Jazeera, and you will not reach the level of hatred of Channel 14 for the State of Israel and its citizens. I would say they are agents of the enemy, but no. They – the owners of the channel, and those responsible for items like this – are the enemy in and of themselves,” journalist Yehuda Shohat posted on X.
Comments are closed.