GOP’s Border Security Bill Should Include Citizenship Verification For Health Care Handouts: A Border Security Measure Should Include a Logical Complement: Enhanced Citizenship Verification Procedures for Federal Health Care Programs
GOP’s Border Security Bill Should Include Citizenship Verification For Health Care Handouts:
A border security measure should include a logical complement: enhanced citizenship verification procedures for federal health care programs.
Incoming Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., has outlined a strategy for the new Republican Congress to address border and national security needs early this year in a budget reconciliation bill. As I explained two years ago, increasing defense spending via reconciliation would circumvent perpetual Democrat demands to couple increases in defense and nondefense spending, which have led to costly omnibus spending bills.
But a border security measure should also include a logical complement: enhanced citizenship verification procedures for federal health care programs. These measures would not just help pay for new security spending but also deter additional migration.
Weak Verification of Citizenship
While federal law has required applicants for many programs to declare their citizenship status since 1986, for decades most states took little action to verify these declarations. In July 2005, the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General released a report noting that 47 state Medicaid programs always or often allowed self-declaration of citizenship and that 27 states took no action to verify those self-declarations. Within months, the Republican-controlled Congress in Section 6036 of the Deficit Reduction Act required Medicaid programs to review “satisfactory documentary evidence of the citizenship or nationality of the individual.”
No sooner had these requirements taken effect in July 2006 than Democrats, who regained control of Congress that November, began working to circumvent them. In 2007, as part of legislation reauthorizing the children’s health insurance program, they proposed an alternative verification mechanism based on matching an applicant’s name and Social Security number. While this mechanism could potentially verify citizenship status, it does not confirm the applicant’s identity, thereby encouraging fraud.
President George W. Bush twice vetoed Democrat bills containing the more lenient verification regime in 2007, but Barack Obama signed the measure into law shortly after taking office in February 2009. Democrats utilized a similar measure when crafting Obamacare later in 2009; Section 1411 of the law relies upon the same Social Security match mechanism.
Republican Outrage — Then Capitulation
In September 2009, the immigration issue soared in prominence when Rep. Joe Wilson, R-S.C., exclaimed, “You lie!” in response to Obama’s claim in his address to Congress that “the reforms I’m proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally.” While Wilson objected to an initial House bill with no citizenship verification provisions at all, the enacted version of Obamacare signed into law again required verification of citizenship but not identity. During the debate over the law, then-Rep. Jim Moran, D-Va., demanded that a constituent show identification before asking a question at a raucous town hall, raising an obvious question: Why not extend the same requirement to applicants for taxpayer-funded benefits? —>READ MORE HERE